Finance Bill withdrawal triggers proposed budget cuts and legislative challenges.
On June 26, President William Ruto presented a memorandum to Parliament formally withdrawing the controversial Finance Bill, 2024, which would have become law after 14 days without it.
In his memorandum, President Ruto said that taking into consideration the widespread public dissatisfaction with the content of the Finance Bill, 2024, and in the exercise of the powers conferred to him by Article 115(1)(b) of the Constitution, he had declined to assent to the Bill.
“I decline to assent to the Finance Bill, 2024, and refer the Bill for reconsideration by the National Assembly with the recommendation for the deletion of all clauses thereof,” he said in the Presidential Memorandum of Referral.
What next?
The Bill will be referred back to the National Assembly with a memorandum detailing reasons for declining to assent it into law. The leader of the Majority Party in the 13th Parliament, Kimani Ichung’wa, will move a motion seeking the House’s concurrence with the President’s recommendations as provided under the Standing Orders. Then, a resolution will be passed that will see the Bill withdrawn in its entirety.
From July 1, the government will continue collecting revenue under the Finance Act of 2023, which is already in place.
According to economists, the controversial Finance Bill, 2024, was not meant to raise the 2024/25 financial year government revenue of KSh3.4 trillion; rather, it contained tax measures intended to raise an additional tax of KSh346 billion only. Hence, the Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) will continue collecting the targeted KSh3.4 trillion, less the KSh346 billion.
However, the government will find itself unable to legislate a new Appropriation Act, which is the written law that guides spending in the absence of a Finance Act. This is because, in 2023, a High Court ruling underlined that the revenue-raising measures must first be approved before the Appropriation Bill is introduced in the National Assembly.
Proposed expenditure cuts
Since the revenue-raising measures in the Finance Bill, 2024, were not approved, there will likely be a revenue shortfall of approximately KSh200 billion.
In order to remain within the provisions of Section 40(5)(a) and Section 50 of the Public Finance Management Act (PFMA), 2012 Cap. 412A—an Act of Parliament that provides for the effective management of public finances by both the national and county governments—the National Treasury proposed measures that will see general expenditure cuts across the three arms of government.
These proposed budget reductions will necessitate amendments to the Appropriations Bill, 2024, following the withdrawal of the Finance Bill, 2024.
The following are the proposed reductions in the budget that will necessitate amendments to the Appropriation Bill.
Operations under the Office of the President | KSh451 million |
---|---|
Operations under the State House | KSh500 million |
Security operations under Internal Security | KSh2 billion |
Reduction in the budget for various RDAs | KSh4.6 billion |
Security operations and modernisation under the Ministry of Defence | KSh7.75 billion |
Foreign relations and diplomacy | KSh1.85 billion |
Ongoing TVETs and TTIs projects | KSh800 million |
Funding for the Differentiated Unit Cost model in universities | KSh2.1 billion |
Higher Education Loans Board (HELB) | KSh3.2 billion |
University infrastructure projects | KSh3 billion |
Infrastructure for primary and secondary schools | KSh1.6 billion |
School feeding program | KSh1.8 billion |
Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) | KSh4.7 billion |
Kenya Airways (KQ) | KSh4.7 billion |
Civil Servants Insurance Scheme | KSh1 billion |
Equalisation Fund arrears | KSh1 billion |
Pending Bills | KSh5 billion |
NGCDF | KSh15 billion |
Provision for Medical Interns | KSh3.7 billion |
Managed Equipment Service (MES) under the State Department for Medical Services | KSh1 billion |
Ongoing roads projects | KSh15.1 billion |
Construction of markets | KSh2.1 billion |
Various irrigation projects | KSh3.7 billion |
Galana Kulalu irrigation project | KSh1 billion |
Various projects under the water works development agencies | KSh11.6 billion |
Land resettlement | KSh1 billion |
ICT Authority | KSh6.7 billion |
Sports academies | KSh1.8 billion |
State Department for Energy, cancellation of the KSh50 million per constituency last mile connectivity and other interventions | KSh14.5 billion |
Last-mile connectivity and street lighting | KSh7.27 billion |
Deferment of the livestock restocking | KSh1 billion |
Fertiliser subsidy (farmers to pay more) | KSh5 billion |
Arrears to farmers under sugar reforms | KSh1.7 billion |
New KCC mop-up of milk | KSh1 billion |
Coffee cherry fund | KSh1 billion |
County Aggregation Industrial Parks | KSh1.6 billion |
Cash transfer program | KSh5.5 billion |
NGAAF | recurrent KSh900 billion (provision of sanitary towels) and development KSh600 million |
Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (EACC) | KSh200 million |
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) | KSh195 million |
Political parties fund | KSh900 million |
Tree planting | KSh1 billion |
National Lands Commission | KSh90 million |
Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) | KSh185 million |
Commission on Revenue Allocation (CRA) | KSh20.65 million |
Public Service Internship program | KSh1 billion |
Salaries and Remuneration Commission (SRC) | KSh23.6 million |
Deferment in confirmation of interns to permanent & pensionable and hiring (JSS) | KSh18.9 billion |
National Police Service Commission (NPSC) | KSh50 million |
The Auditor General | KSh410 million |
Office of Controller of Budget (COB) | KSh37 million |
Commission on Administrative Justice | KSh33 million |
National Gender and Equality Commission (NGEC) | KSh21.25 million |
Independent Policing Oversight Authority (IPOA) | KSh55 million |
Judiciary recurrent budget | KSh2 billion |
Parliament – domestic travel, foreign travel, reversal of office operations and salary increment for staff, Bunge Towers and CPST project | KSh3.15 billion |
County Equitable Share | KSh5 billion |